Accessible Search Form           Advanced Search

Skip left side navigation and go to content

CRG Home

Did the reviewers like my application?

Reviewer's enthusiasm for your application will be reflected in an overall impact/priority score, and scores for each review criterion. Criterion. scores range from "1" (exceptionally strong with essentially no weaknesses) to "9" (serious and substantive weaknesses with very few strengths), reflecting scientific and technical merit. The five scored criteria for research grant applications are Significance, Investigator(s), Innovation, Approach, and Environment and more detail can be found in "Review Criteria at a Glance".

The overall impact/priority score will range from "10" to "90", and is calculated from the mean of the overall scores voted by all eligible panel members (not just the assigned reviewers), multiplied by a factor of 10. The overall score is not the mean of the criterion scores, but is a separate score reflecting the varying weight the reviewer applied to the individual criteria. The impact score is not the same as the "old" priority score. Impact score indicates the importance or impact the study will have on the field. Applications unanimously judged by the peer review committee to be less competitive are not discussed at the meeting and will not receive an overall impact score.

Within a few days after the meeting your Priority score and Percentile ranking are available to you online via the NIH Commons. Within a month, the scientific review administrator( SRA ) will prepare the Summary Statement which will be available via your NIH Commons account. Whether or not your application was discussed, you will receive the reviewer critiques and preliminary scores for each review criterion. Go to the Commons website for information on how a username and password can be obtained.

Based on priority score, competitive applications for some mechanisms receive a Percentile rank, indicating its rank relative to others reviewed by its review group at the current and past two review meetings. At NHLBI, an application's percentile rank is the basis for funding decisions of R01 and R21 awards. However, SBIR, STTR. K awards and other awards receive only a priority score.

Page Last Updated: February 2011
Content Manager: ClinicalResearchPolicyManager@nhlbi.nih.gov

Twitter iconTwitterimage of external icon Facebook iconFacebookimage of external icon YouTube iconYouTubeimage of external icon Google+ iconGoogle+image of external icon